Digital or Acoustic?
Dear Greg,
I own a yamaha P250 ditigal piano and its really nice. The only thing is I just don't get that "acoustic" feel. It sounds just like an acoustic, though I still don't get that feel..I occassionally go to Eastman school of music to use their pianos, but it uses a bit too much gas.. And I 'm only there like once a week for 2 hours. My parents currently cant afford an acoustic, especially since the American ecomony is down. Do you think after this ecomony thing I should ask my parents to begin to invest in a real one? Or do you think I should just stick with the P250 until I move out and buy my own? -Kalen
Dear Kalen,
It's not just the feel, but the *sound* of digital keyboards that will hinder your growth as a pianist. Digital keyboards are unable to recreate the natural blend of overtones heard on a real piano; furthermore, they lack the immense variety of tonal "colors" that a real piano can create. As a pianist, it is necessary to learn to control these colors and overtones in beautiful ways. Developing your skills on a digital keyboard will weaken your ear's ability to hear these differences and it will prevent you from truly learning to exploit the tonal possibilities of a piano.
That said, you probably should evaluate your priorities first. If your number one priority is to become a classical pianist, then you really should be training on an acoustic piano, preferably a grand piano. If playing the piano is just one of many things you enjoy in life, then perhaps you should stick with the keyboard. Keyboards certainly have many advantages (I use my Yamaha P80 quite often!): they stay in tune, they make less noise, they hook up to a computer, and they are more affordable. For an aspiring concert pianist, however, these advantages are small when compared to the feel and sound of a real piano.
- Greg
Balancing a Professional Career
Hello Greg!,
You are such an inspiration for me! I've been playing piano since i was 8 and i am now 13 years old. Just a couple months back, I was thinking about my future, and I finally decided that I wanted to become a professional pianist. I know it would take a lot of dedication and time, but I have decided that once I get out of High School I am also going to be a Lawyer or Doctor, and I plan to make time for piano. I dont know how well that would go, because my mother does not approve of me becoming a professional, so she won't let me attend Julliard. So, do you have any advice to give me?..Do you think I would be able to become a professional after years more of training? I mean, I would like to perform, but not to big audiences and not at concerts...just at small things like Church, or weddings or such. I do not plan to travel the world and spread my piano playing. My teacher has told me that for the last two years i have been playing extraordinarily well! and he says that he is proud of me for that, but do you think with all my lawyer and doctor stuff that i'll still be able to become a professional? Once again, I dont want to be known worldwide or nationally..i just want to have the ability to play the most advanced piano pieces...thank you Greg! I hope you reply to this message!
- Catherine
Dear Catherine,
Wow! You have big plans! ... a doctor, a lawyer, a musician! Good for you. The description you provided in your question sounds entirely reasonable. Unlike becoming a pianist, becoming a doctor or a lawyer does not require decades and decades of training. In other words, you can start training to be a doctor when you're 30, and you can still make a career out of it; it is highly improbable that someone could start playing the piano at age 30 and make concertizing their career.
I know dozens of medical and law students at Yale who majored in music before coming to Yale -- no pre-med degrees, no science degrees, no political science degrees before coming -- just music degrees. The medical school at Yale is so supportive of music that they have a full symphony orchestra; they had over 200 medical students and residents audition for the orchestra last year!
Practice hard and have fun. There is no need to stress out; with your goals, you should be able to do it all.
- Greg (Oct. 25, 2009)
Juilliard Acceptance
Hi Greg!
I am fifteen years old and I deeply want to study piano performance along with composition and theory at a university level by the time I am finished with my high school career. I understand that every school is different in its standards, but I can't help but ask: How tough is a Julliard audition and gaining acceptance? I ask because you've been a massive inspiration to me and my "quest" in studying at a university level.
- Chad Aboukaram
Hi Chad,
Ummmmmm..... I'm not sure how to answer that question. :-) "How tough is a Juilliard audition and gaining acceptance?" The answer is very subjective; for some people it's a piece of cake, for others it's more akin to eating a bed of nails.
The acceptance rate for the school is somewhere close to 10%; the acceptance rate for the piano department is lower, closer to 5%. This is what I've heard, though I don't have the evidence to back up those figures.
Thank you for your nice words, and I wish you the very best!
- Greg (Oct. 25, 2009)
Tackling Bach's Repertoire
Dear Greg,
I have heard many piano teachers talk about the order in which Bach's repertoire should be studied... I start with a summer teacher soon and I am looking at new repertoire. I have never played a prelude and fugue or a suite. Some people say you study Bach in the following order: Inventions, Sinfonia, Suites (French then English), The Well Tempered Clavier and Partitas. Some people say after playing inventions you should start on the WTC and then suites. Where does the Italian Concerto fit in? ... I think you have to look at the individual student and see what that student needs at that time. What do you think?
Trent
Dear Trent,
I am no piano teacher, nor do I pretend to be, but I definitely agree with your opinion on this matter. From my perspective, the inventions, partitas, and everything in between are beautiful works of art and are terribly difficult to play. I think it's a shame the inventions, sinfonia, and the Well-Tempered Clavier are universally treated as "teaching pieces;" they have developed a certain stigma as a result. Concert pianists tend to avoid all but the partitas, the concerto, and the Goldberg Variations in their concert programs, as if they won't be taken seriously were they to play an invention here and a prelude and fugue there. The work-around our society has developed for this problem? - to program all 15 sinfonia, all six French Suites, or the complete Well-Tempered Clavier in one sitting. Those encyclopedic Gods! They are so impressive! (Fans self.)
Do audiences really want to listen to all six French Suites in one go? One is so beautiful all by itself. A hundred years ago, pianists would even create a small suite of their own, compiling their favorite movements from different suites. Sometimes "simple" and "easy" can be bracing, beautiful, and bewitching.
Anyway - I say, play them in whatever order suits you. If you are so inclined to start the Goldberg Variations now, then go for it! You wouldn't necessarily need to perform the work for another decade or so, but that's beyond the point. The intrinsic motivation of practicing what you love does a lot more for a person than routine exercises ever will.
There's another side of me screaming: "bad advice, bad advice!" Yes, maybe you should listen to your teacher - he or she certainly has your best interests in mind. Just remember, all of Bach's works have different challenges; there is no need to attack and conquer one genre at a time.
- Greg
Nokia
Hi Greg!
I'm impressed! I want to know if its possible to get the sheet music of you piano variations on a theme by Nokia! thanks
- Rafael
Dear Rafael,
Thank you for your interest! Unfortunately there are copyright issues for me to untangle before I could ever begin to think about publishing the score. Today's modern world makes it very difficult for classical composers to reference popular culture sources. Saint-Saëns' Carnival of the Animals, nearly all of Liszt's transcriptions, paraphrases, and reminiscences, and most of Mozart's variation sets would have been extremely difficult to compose in today's labyrinthian world of copyright law.
Someday, when I have an army of lawyers at my disposal, perhaps I can consider publishing my variations and Star Wars Fantasy. For now, the following adaptations composed by me are for sale:
- Khachaturian's Sabre Dance for piano/four-hands
- Bach's "Erbarme Dich" from St. Matthew Passion for two pianos
- Saint-Saëns' The Swan for two pianos
- The Cuckoo in Sussex by Daquin/Anderson for two pianos
- Schubert's "The Crow" from Winterreisse for two pianos
- The Cat's Fugue for two pianos
There are a number of other adaptations for two pianos, four-hands, six-hands, and five pianos temporarily under exclusivity clauses. Follow us on Facebook or sign up for the mailing list for updates regarding these pieces.
- Greg
Going Solo
Hey Greg!
I am a 32 yr. old with a schedule that's near impossible to throw in professional lessons or attend school. At least for the next year or so. I took one semester of piano in college but have always loved classical music. I just recently purchased a Yamaha digital piano. My practice time is usually 30 to 60 minutes, around 2 or 3 in the am 4x a week. Been like this for approx. 3 months now. I love the piano, and my goal is to be able to play pieces like Hungarian Rhapsody #2 by Liszt. But what advice can you give an adult in my position who's learning to play the piano on his own and can not get pro help?? What should I concentrate on? Any books or exercises you recommend? Thanks!
Will
Dear Will,
I can't pretend to offer you any useful advice; I have only taught a few students in my life, and I have the distinct feeling that I learned more from them than they learned from me. However, I firmly believe that with the kind of determination you have shown, your dream will become a reality. If you are enjoying yourself, it's easy to work hard. If you work hard, it's easy to improve. You're on the right track!
- Greg
Nerves
Greg,
Could you outline what is involved in preparing mentally and physically for a solo performance? Furthermore, as I am a shy person by nature, I suffer from nerves in performance situations. If you have and information or advice on ways to overcome this, it would be greatly appreciated. Thank you very much for your time and consideration.
Juvena
Dear Juvena,
You've asked a very tricky question to answer. Over the years, I've actually found that the less I think about nerves, memory, and pre-concert preparation, the better! I used to have a pre-concert routine worked out, but I found that it was just a waste of time and it made me more nervous. Instead, I now acknowledge my nerves, but I don't dwell on them. I try to stay focused and secluded, but I'm easy going and allow for "emergencies." I try to find time to warm up, but I don't get my undies in a bunch if I can't.
It really only takes a brief, concentrated moment and a couple deep breaths to center oneself. If you make a big deal out of it, chances are things won't go the way you planned and you'll walk onstage flustered and frustrated. I prefer to walk onstage without any expectations, but ready to seize the moment.
Most important of all, remember to enjoy the music!
- Greg
Practicing Routine
Greg,
What is a typical practice routine for you? Not how long really but how do you like to practice? What approach do you take in learning a new piece?
LH
Dear LH,
All these questions about practicing and performing make me wonder if I ought to develop a fancy routine, just to impress you all.
You will be incredibly disappointed to learn that I usually just sit down at the piano and start playing. Someday, my body will give way, and it'll probably take a bit more time to warm up, but for now, I find that as long as my mind is clear, and as long as I'm not playing something with extremely fast finger work, and as long as I wasn't just outside in negative 30 degree weather, I'm fine.
I usually just play whatever I feel like practicing. Often times this happens to correspond with what I need to be practicing, say, for an upcoming concert (that "need" to practice leads me to "feel" like practicing). But even in such circumstances, I often find myself sight-reading different music to suit my moods.
As for learning a new piece, my approach depends on the music itself and the deadline I'm facing. If I'm in a hurry, I learn passage-at-a-time until I've got the whole piece in my fingers. If I've got time (the preferred method of doing things!), I learn the piece very slowly and very carefully. This aids memorization and appreciation of the music itself.
There is one thing I never do when learning a new piece: listen to a recording. Only when I'm ready to perform a work will I allow myself to hear another interpretation. I want the music to mean something unique to me, and I find that when I listen to recordings, I tend to fuse my personal experience with the music with another's.
- Greg
Bored
Dear Greg,
I recently expressed to my piano teacher that I wanted to start playing more advanced music. She appreciates this and agreed to find some more level appropriate stuff. But the thing is, all she wants me to play is Bach! She explained how I have to understand and master the early preludes and whatnot to be able to bring out the themes in the harder pieces like fugues later on. But one thing about me as a pianist is that sometimes I just can't bring myself to play a piece if I dislike it or am BORED with it. The latter of which is exactly what the preludes and musettes do to me. So, do you have any suggestions on how to make them more interesting/fun or maybe some equally leveled pieces? Even though my teacher agreed to give me harder pieces, the music she's had me playing still seems too easy (i.e. Kuhlau and Clementi sonatinas, Kabalevsky's Toccatina). Thanks!
- Caitie
Dear Caitie,
I'm sorry Caitie, but I can't bring myself to disagree with your teacher! I've never heard you play and I'm unaware of the reasons your teacher has asked you to practice lots of Bach and easy material (and you may not be aware either!).
You can start by making sure she knows how you feel, but remember that you're paying her for a reason. Sometimes you have to follow your teacher's advice, even if it isn't what you want to do. Watch Karate Kid for a powerful example of this in action.
Also, remember that Kuhlau and Cleminti sonatinas are not easy. There's no end to the detail, refinement, and control one can aim for in those pieces. And if you're really that bored, find a way to interest yourself. Turn the different voices in Bach's music into different characters. Is one a jester? a campy diva? a doleful mother? a loyal friend? How can you bring out their personalities in the way you play their musical lines? How do these different personalities interact in the musical counterpoint? Turn the sonatinas into miniature operas! Play as if you're playing at a funeral. a wedding! a political gathering! As I said in a previous question, play as if it is the last time you'll ever play the piano!
It's up to you to make sure you have a good time!
- Greg